Muhammadiyah's Criticism Towards Government Policies in The Era of Din Syamsudin’s Leadership

Tohari Tohari, Sjafri Sairin, Muhammad Azhar, Muhammad Nurul Yamin


The liberalization policy through Law No. 7 of 2004 concerning Natural Resources and Law No. 22 of 2001 concerning Oil and Gas, elicited a strong reaction from the Muhammadiyah movement. In response to the laws, Muhammadiyah used their role as both a civil society movement and Islamic movement and took the step of constitutional jihad. This article looks at the steps and attitudes of Muhammadiyah's criticism towards government policies under the administration of President Susilo Bambang Yudoyono (SBY). The findings showed the constitutional jihad was based on the spirit of the Muhammadiyah indictment and the spirit of progressive Islam Muhammdiyah. It was within this spirit that the Muhammadiyah movement was encouraged to be critical of SBY's policies. This study also explores Muhammadiyah's critical attitude which has had an internal and external impacts on the movement as a whole and Muhammadiyah leaders. Muhammadiyah's critical attitude is a form of action and rational choice. The rational choice being made by Muhammadiyah through observation of the impacts of the application of the two laws. Muhammadiyah and its leaders indicate the rational choice of Muhammadiyah actors based on Muhammadiyah's spirit orientation, and the social conditions of the Indonesians in response to the application of both of these laws.


Muhammadiyah; Criticism; Oil and Gas; Natural Resources; Law

Full Text:



Al-ansi, A. M., Sulistyaningsih, T., & Kartono, R. (2019). Rational Choice of Following Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama and Their Social and Political Role in Indonesian Society. Open Access Library Journal, 6, 1–14.

Andrew-Hindmoor, B. T. (2015). The Rational Choice. In The rational choice, London: Palgrave.

Argenti, G. (2017). Civil Society Dan Politik Moral Muhammadiyah. Jurnal Politikom Indonesia, 2(2), 82–104.

Bateson, M. (2010). Rational Choice Behavior: Definitions and Evidence. In Encyclopedia of Animal Behavior (Second Edi, Vol. 1).

Boudon, R. (2003). Beyond Rational Choice Theory. Annual Review of Sociology, 29(1), 1–21.

Couture, J. (2012). Cosmopolitan Democracy and Liberal Nationalism. Monist, 82(3), 491–515.

David-Efendi, S. (2017). POLITICS OF EDUCATION: Multiculturalism Practice in Universitas Muhammadiyah Kupang, NTT.

Dekker, S. W. A. (2017). Rasmussen’s legacy and the long arm of rational choice. Applied Ergonomics, 59, 554–557.

Eckersley, R. (2007). From cosmopolitan nationalism to cosmopolitan democracy. Review of International Studies, 33(4), 675–692.

Faris, N., & Parry, K. (2011). Islamic organizational leadership within a Western society: The problematic role of external context. Leadership Quarterly, 22(1), 132–151.

Freedman, A. L. (2009). Civil Society, Moderate Islam, and Politics in Indonesia and Malaysia. Journal of Civil Society, 5(2), 107–127.

Gallagher, K. P., & Tian, Y. (2017). Regulating capital flows in emerging markets: The IMF and the global financial crisis. Review of Development Finance, 7(2), 95–106.

Hadiz, V. R. (2011). Indonesian Political Islam: Capitalist Development and the Legacies of the Cold War. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 30(1), 3–38.

Hakim, M. (1998). The New Order and Indonesian Islam Politics. Ilmu Ushuluddin, 3(1), 23–144.

Hechter, M. (1997). Sociological Rational Choice Theory. Annual Review of Sociology, (23), 191–214.

Hoffman, T. (2015). Rational Choice and Political Irrationality in the New Millennium. Critical Review, 27(3–4), 299–315.

Jason, F., Asaacnon, C. R. (2017). Islam in Asia, Changing Political Realities. In American Jewish Committee. Routledge Taylor and Francis Group.

Jb, M., & Darmawan, L. (2016). Wacana Civil Society (Masyarakat Madani) Di Indonesia. Jurnal Sosiologi Reflektif, 10(2), 35.

Jung, D. J. (2017). Irrationalizing the rational choice model of voting: The moderating effects of partisanship on turnout decisions in Western and postcommunist democracies. Electoral Studies, 50, 26–38.

Kaptein, N. J. G. (2016). Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: Tolerance without Liberalism, written by Jeremy Menchik. Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde / Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences of Southeast Asia, 172(4), 580–581.

Kaptein, N. J. G. (2019). Review Reviewed Work ( s ): Islam and Democracy in Indonesia : Tolerance without Liberalism [ Cambridge Studies in Social Theory , Religion and Politics ] by Jeremy Menchik Review by : Nico J . G . Kaptein Published by : Brill Stable URL : https://www.jst. Brill, 172(4), 580–581. Retrieved from

Kentikelenis, A. E., Stubbs, T. H., & King, L. P. (2016). IMF conditionality and development policy space, 1985–2014. Review of International Political Economy, 23(4), 543–582.

Kosasih, A. D., & Suwarno. (2010). Pola Kepemimpinan Organisasi Muhammadiyah. Islamadina, IX(1), 30–46.

Manalu, D. (2019). Book Review: Islamic Political Discourse in the Reform Era. PCD Journal, 6(2), 335.

Mark, E., Warren, H. P. (2008). Design Deliberative Democracy.

McBride, M. (2016). A rational choice theory of religious authority. Rationality and Society, 28(4), 410–438.

Moser, S. (2006). Indonesia. Islam and the State in Indonesia. By BAHTIAR EFFENDY. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2003. Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 37(1), 165–167.

Mu’ti, A. (2016). Akar Pluralisme dalam pendidikan Muhammadiyah. Afkaruna, 12(1), 1–42.

Muhammadiyah, T. (2010). Keputusan Muktamar Muhammadiyah ke 46 Tentang Revitalisasi Kader dan Anggota Muhammadiyah (pp. 107–129). pp. 107–129.

Munson, Z. (2001). Islamic Mobilization Social Movement Theory adn the Egypatian Muslim Brotherhood. The Sociological Quarterly, 42(1), 487–509.

Nashir, H., Qodir, Z., Nurmandi, A., Jubba, H., & Hidayati, M. (2019). Muhammadiyah’s Moderation Stance in the 2019 General Election: Critical Views from Within. Al-Jami'ah: Journal of Islamic Studies, 57(1), 1-24. doi:

Nursita, R., & Sahide, A. (2019). The Concept of Peace in Islam and Its Relevance to International Relations. Al-Albab, 8(2), 211 - 224. doi:


Parmudi, M. (2015). Kebangkitan Civil Society di Indonesia. At-Taqaddum, 7(2), 295–310.

PETER-HEDSTRÖM, C. S. (2011). Rational choice theory. The SAGE Handbook of Governance, 36–50.

Ratcliffe, P. (2014). Rational Choice Theory. Ethnic Group, 1–10.

Sabic-El-Rayess, A. (2020). Epistemological shifts in knowledge and education in Islam: A new perspective on the emergence of radicalization amongst Muslims. International Journal of Educational Development, 73(November 2019), 102148.

Saguni, M. K. (2018). Muhammadiyah Paradigma Gerakan Sosial Keagamaan. Nukbahtul Ulum, JUrnal Kajian Islam, 4(1), 21–30.

Schumpeter, J. (1942). Capitalsims, Socialism, and Democracy. J. Econ. Literatur, Vol. 20, p. 1463.

Setyawan, D. (2013). Analisis Hubungan Ijtihad Dan Tajdid Pemikiran Ekonomi Terhadap Perkembangan Usaha (Studi kasus Pada Amal Usaha Organisasi Masyarakat Muhammadiyah). Jurnal EKONOMI ISLAM, 2(1), 105–134.

Simon-Butt, F. S. (2013). Analisis Kritik Terhadap Putusan Mahkama Konstitusi Nomor 36/PUU-X/20212. Mimbar Hukum, 25(1), 1–12.

Somer, M. (2007). Moderate Islam and secularist opposition in Turkey: Implications for the world, Muslims and secular democracy. Third World Quarterly, 28(7), 1271–1289.

Susanto, H. (2011). Democracy in Islam: Comparative study of Muhammad Abid al-Jabiri and Abdolkarim Soroush’s thoughts. Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies, 1(2), 253–272.

Svolik, M. W. (2019). Democracy as an equilibrium: rational choice and formal political theory in democratization research. Democratization, 26(1), 40–60.

Sweetman, J., Maio, G. R., Spears, R., Manstead, A. S. R., & Livingstone, A. G. (2019). Attitude toward protest uniquely predicts (normative and nonnormative) political action by (advantaged and disadvantaged) group members. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 82(January 2018), 115–128.

van Aaken, A., & Kurtz, J. (2019). Beyond Rational Choice: International Trade Law and the Behavioral Political Economy of Protectionism. SSRN Electronic Journal, (December), 601–628.

Villamayor-Tomas, S., Thiel, A., Amblard, L., Zikos, D., & Blanco, E. (2019). Diagnosing the role of the state for local collective action: Types of action situations and policy instruments. Environmental Science and Policy, 97(February), 44–57.

Warner, C. M., & Wenner, M. W. (2006). Religion and the Political Organization of Muslims in Europe. Perspectives on Politics, 4(03), 457–479.

Wiratraman, H. P. (2018). Constitutional Court and Democracy in Indonesia, by Simon Butt. Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde / Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences of Southeast Asia, 174(1), 84–87.

Zafirovski, M. (2016). Rational Choice Theory at the Origin? Forms and Social Factors of “Irrational Choice.” Social Epistemology, 30(5–6), 728–763.

Article Metrics

Abstract views: 365 PDF views: 307